FeedPetWiseFeeding tools with visible assumptions

Label, equipment and record information · Updated

Marketing Claims vs. Nutrition Facts

Separate the package claim from adequacy, nutrient guarantees, ingredients and calorie units. Use a real manufacturer-page example without ranking foods.

Write the claim and the actual question separately

Start by copying the exact claim from the current package or manufacturer page and identifying what you need to decide. “Premium,” a high-protein headline and a calorie number answer different questions. A strong-sounding phrase does not replace the nutritional adequacy statement, complete ingredient list, guaranteed analysis or serving information.

AAFCO's consumer FAQ says “premium” is not a term with special pet-food requirements in feed law. It also says AAFCO does not approve, certify or endorse pet foods. A reference to an AAFCO nutrient profile therefore must not become “AAFCO approved” in your notes or a shopping comparison.

The discussion here uses US dog/cat label guidance. It does not establish labeling law for every market. Read the current package for the actual recipe and intended species; an online description is a source to compare, not proof that every bag now sold carries the same wording.

Match a decision to the field that can answer it

On a narrow screen, scroll this table sideways to read all columns.

Claim-to-evidence map
QuestionRelevant field or evidenceShortcut to avoid
Is this intended as a complete diet for the relevant species and life stage?Full nutritional adequacy statement and intended feeding role.A premium, natural or similar front-panel word.
What does the nutrient panel guarantee?Each row with its minimum/maximum wording and units.Treating a guarantee as exact measured composition.
Which ingredients are listed?Complete current ingredient statement.Treating the main recipe name as the entire ingredient list.
How much label energy is in a known amount?Matching as-fed Calorie Content and serving definition.Converting a protein percentage into kcal.
Does a claimed outcome apply to this individual pet?Relevant evidence and appropriate veterinary assessment where health is involved.Treating a product description as an individual clinical result.

A statement can have a defined labeling role without answering every question a shopper asks. “Complete and balanced” concerns the product's nutritional adequacy role, with species and life-stage context. It is not a promise of a particular pet's tolerance, a disease treatment or identical feeding amounts for all animals.

For the adequacy evidence wording itself, use the formulation/feeding-test worksheet. Do not turn that method into a universal brand ranking.

Read one manufacturer page as separate evidence fields

The reviewed Nulo Frontrunner Ancient Grains Beef, Barley & Lamb dog-food page contains both promotional descriptions and specific ingredient, analysis and calorie fields. We use it as a dated reading example, not an endorsement or an independent verification of its health claims. The current exact bag still needs to be matched.

Its calorie statement says ME calculated, 3,677 kcal/kg and 433 kcal/cup. Its crude-protein guarantee is minimum 27%, crude fat minimum 16%, crude fiber maximum 4%, and moisture maximum 10%. Those four qualifiers matter: minimum 16% fat does not state a maximum of 16% or an actual measured value of 16%.

The ingredient list begins with deboned beef, chicken meal, oats, barley and brown rice; deboned lamb appears later. Reading the full list reveals more ingredients than the recipe name. Listing ingredients does not provide each ingredient's exact percentage, digestibility or an individual allergy assessment.

The page's nutrition statement identifies formulation to the AAFCO nutrient profiles for maintenance. Record that actual wording without upgrading it to a direct feeding-test claim or approval. Its description uses heart, muscle and digestive-health language, but the label fields just listed do not independently verify an outcome for a particular dog.

Do not combine unlike numbers into a food-quality score

The guarantee percentages include water. A dry-matter calculation from minimum nutrient and maximum moisture is a label-based estimate, not an exact composition or a proved actual dry-matter minimum. Use the guarantee guide and its counterexample rather than ranking two foods by the largest converted number.

Similarly, 433 kcal/cup is a serving statement for that food's cup definition; it does not tell you the mass of your household scoop. The matching kcal/kg can be used with weighed grams, but it still does not set a dog's daily requirement. Keep calorie units and adequacy role separate from the promotional claim.

A lower shopping cost per 1,000 kcal answers a price calculation, not safety, digestibility or medical suitability. The existing cost calculator already handles that calculation and its limitations.

Ask for the information the claim does not supply

A useful manufacturer question specifies the recipe, current package and missing field: “This is the statement on my bag; can you confirm the current as-fed calorie data and the cup definition?” For a nutrient comparison, request matching analysis and its basis/date instead of treating the guaranteed minimum as a typical average.

If a health outcome claim is the deciding factor, ask what evidence supports that exact claim for the actual product and population. Record the study or response you really receive and what remains unknown. Do not invent a favorable review, a test result or a veterinarian's endorsement to fill that gap.

Bring an individual diet or health question to the veterinary team with the exact labels, current diet and actual observations. AAFCO says it does not provide veterinary medical advice. A record can narrow the question; it cannot choose treatment or authorize changes to a veterinarian-directed diet.

Complete one claim record with the actual wording, source/date, separate label fields, a bounded conclusion and the next unresolved question. That is a checkable decision aid even when the available evidence cannot settle the purchase or health question.

Use the original editable record

Download this record (TXT). Enter actual facts in your own file; keep unknown information visible. This page does not collect your answers.

PET-FOOD CLAIM / EVIDENCE READING RECORD
Exact current product / market / package or webpage reference:
Claim copied verbatim / source / date:
Reader question (adequacy, ingredients, energy, nutrient data or outcome):
Full adequacy statement / species / life stage / feeding role:
Guaranteed-analysis rows with qualifiers and units:
Complete ingredient-list reference:
Calorie Content / stated method / units / serving definition:
Additional evidence actually obtained (not inferred):
What this evidence supports:
What it does not establish:
Manufacturer question / actual response / unresolved field:
Individual veterinary question where relevant:
Does a reference to an AAFCO profile mean AAFCO approved the product?

No. AAFCO says it does not approve, certify or endorse pet foods. Keep the actual adequacy wording and evidence method.

Sources and what they support

  1. AAFCO: Reading LabelsSeparate label fields, nutrient minimum/maximum wording, ingredient list and adequacy statement formats in the US model context.
  2. AAFCO: Consumer FAQsNo AAFCO product approval; premium terminology and veterinary-care boundary. No clinical advice or universal best-food ranking.
  3. FDA: Complete and Balanced Pet FoodUS adequacy role and life-stage context; its comparison example does not prove exact actual composition from guarantees.
  4. AAFCO: CaloriesCalorie Content, kcal/kg as-fed and familiar units; historical 2014 transition wording is not a current deadline.
  5. Nulo: Frontrunner Ancient Grains Beef, Barley & Lamb dog-food pageAttributed current manufacturer ingredient list, guaranteed bounds, calculated energy and adult-maintenance formulation statement for this exact recipe.

Records and teaching examples are original. Manufacturer statements are attributed; no product test, veterinary reviewer, individual diet prescription or clinical outcome is claimed.